All Manga, Character Designs and Logos are © to their respective copyright holders.
A Tree Without Roots
뿌리 없는 나무; A tree without roots
LATEST CHAPTERS
We need your help. We are re-building the ranking system, so please write a review for the manga you know.
It helps others easily decide to read this manga or not. Thanks.
WRITE A REVIEW
SUMMARY
REVIEWS (86)
not found...
SHOW MORE
BLMangaRecommender
12 days ago
Rocks
*sigh* SH** IS EATING BRO IM INLOVE
Reply
(1)
a month ago
Meh
Well both the ML's are mentally ill and didn't and couldn't seek therapy so don't expect that it would be a loving romantic story a normal couple would have , because that would be unrealistic in this case when both are mentally fuc*** up , don't expect anything normal because if you do you won't be able to understand it or complete it 😁
Reply
(1)
2 months ago
Pretty good
I like it have plot and beautiful art style and storyline is good just those r@pe and violence too much : [
Reply
(11)
(2)
3 months ago
Rocks
Starts off a lil bit slow but ch 71 to 73 ~~ ilive for that !
Reply
(2)
(2)
5 months ago
Kinda bad
Lowkey is was invested in the story. Although it was toxic it is a psychologcal adult drama (I think?) and it is meant to be heavier and contain more "disturbing" content. But as much as I can handle chapter 73 was just
Spoiler!
so disgusting, disturbing, distasteful, abominable, gross and filthy just made me want to throw up ugh who thought this was good idea
So much so now I'm thinking about dropping this
I recommended either skip it or just not start this
Reply
(10)
(1)
5 months ago
Sucks big time
Just abuse, it was good for a while but not around chapter 70+ it started to go too far with the abuse and manipulation. I tried to read more but I end up skipping every chapter because it's just about the blonde guy thrusting inside the bottom without consent. So if you're into that, go for it ig
Reply
(10)
(1)
5 months ago
Sucks big time
A di ck without root
Reply
(14)
(3)
6 months ago
Kinda bad
Listen to these reviews for ur own good. (I meant 1-2 star ones cuz they're probably right)
ppl justifying ml's actions scare me lol. "He loves him and only wants him
that's why he's doing it"
OKAY? like if someone graped u, constantly tried to kiss u, while u tried to stop them cuz u didn't like them but they love u dearly would u still let them?
Just because they're pretty? They love u? They only want u? That's psychotic.
Y'all just don't realize how deep getting graped is, even SA is traumatizing as he**.
ppl justifying ml's actions scare me lol. "He loves him and only wants him
that's why he's doing it"
OKAY? like if someone graped u, constantly tried to kiss u, while u tried to stop them cuz u didn't like them but they love u dearly would u still let them?
Just because they're pretty? They love u? They only want u? That's psychotic.
Y'all just don't realize how deep getting graped is, even SA is traumatizing as he**.
Reply
(12)
6 months ago
Rocks
People should know what their signing up for, because some shows just aren't for you. To top it off, The amount of hate heesoe get actually pis*** the sh** outta me because people are so brainless to not even consider ANYTHING. It's like y'all skip a bunch of chaps and just watch the sm**.
This story definitely has a strong Storyline and it definitely has a sensitive touch to it, it's interesting and hooking along with involves trauma. And if that's not for you, then you can pack your stuff and leave. Before everything, I will say that Yes heeseo's Feelings are very much valid but his Actions are NOT valid at all. But can we also take notice to the build up to all of that??? do not forget how the bottom is literally an adult (in the start) and heeseo is literally a minor and it is on Mr Cha on how to handle the situation with a child who's literally an orphan, treated like sh** his entire life, and has gone through so much da** fuc**** truama, suicidal thoughts and much more. As an adult from all the ways he could have helped heeseo, he choosed to help him in a sexual way, and literally showed his sexual side to a person who is not familiar with love, affection or thses type of things. Mr Cha (ml, bottom) is responsible for leading heeseo on(telling him he likes him back when he didn't) lying to heeseo very often about his own da** mothers case and poor heeseo while KNOWING that he's being lied to, still held on to him no matter what, only to be coldy and rudey shut off and send away like come on man. Like for fu** sakes that's a lot to go through from, I don't blame him to become messed up later one, he literally just wanted to be loved. Is his feelings valid, yes man, but are his actions valid? Absolutely not. Will I keep bitc**** about it, yes I will.
I just wish people could be more emotionally intelligent to understand this story. Idc I'm team heeseo, but yes I will say he is wrong when he genuinely is wrong and rn, kidnaping and SA is not right.
This story definitely has a strong Storyline and it definitely has a sensitive touch to it, it's interesting and hooking along with involves trauma. And if that's not for you, then you can pack your stuff and leave. Before everything, I will say that Yes heeseo's Feelings are very much valid but his Actions are NOT valid at all. But can we also take notice to the build up to all of that??? do not forget how the bottom is literally an adult (in the start) and heeseo is literally a minor and it is on Mr Cha on how to handle the situation with a child who's literally an orphan, treated like sh** his entire life, and has gone through so much da** fuc**** truama, suicidal thoughts and much more. As an adult from all the ways he could have helped heeseo, he choosed to help him in a sexual way, and literally showed his sexual side to a person who is not familiar with love, affection or thses type of things. Mr Cha (ml, bottom) is responsible for leading heeseo on(telling him he likes him back when he didn't) lying to heeseo very often about his own da** mothers case and poor heeseo while KNOWING that he's being lied to, still held on to him no matter what, only to be coldy and rudey shut off and send away like come on man. Like for fu** sakes that's a lot to go through from, I don't blame him to become messed up later one, he literally just wanted to be loved. Is his feelings valid, yes man, but are his actions valid? Absolutely not. Will I keep bitc**** about it, yes I will.
I just wish people could be more emotionally intelligent to understand this story. Idc I'm team heeseo, but yes I will say he is wrong when he genuinely is wrong and rn, kidnaping and SA is not right.
Reply
(7)
(24)
6 months ago
Meh
I wasn't planning on commenting until I finished it, but I feel like the characters haven't made any progress. Top is still in his old broken character and isn't getting better, bottom is constantly trying to escape (he's right btw) but he cares and gives false hope. And I don't know if I'll see a happy ending, to be honest it doesn't seem possible anytime soon. I'm out of patience you know.
Reply
(4)
(2)
7 months ago
Pretty good
forget the rating someone reccomended me this but the reviwes r scaring me shud i read it?????? i feel its mid
Reply
(3)
(2)
7 months ago
Kinda bad
Nah, saw it on TikTok and thought it was good but nothing for me because I hate red flag
Reply
(3)
(2)
7 months ago
Rocks
I love red flags
Reply
(2)
(12)
8 months ago
Kinda bad
its okay. i like it but i also hate it if you get what i mean??
I really hope they get a happy ending but rn its just ONE SIDED LOVE. THe mc tries to run away from the ml after being kidnapped and then the ml just GRAPES him. And this happens TWICE. The art is really pretty though.. I really hope something wholesome happens because i cant bear reading it right now
I really hope they get a happy ending but rn its just ONE SIDED LOVE. THe mc tries to run away from the ml after being kidnapped and then the ml just GRAPES him. And this happens TWICE. The art is really pretty though.. I really hope something wholesome happens because i cant bear reading it right now
Reply
(7)
(4)
8 months ago
Meh
Uhmm i like it but i dont like it? I dont know i like but kidnapping and 🍇 just turns me off, cant u just give them flowers and say "can i court you?" And he** say "no" and then he** say "okay, i hope we can be friends" then leaves and be happy with his single life, am i just delusional?
Reply
(3)
9 months ago
Rocks
Its great
Reply
(4)
(3)
9 months ago
Kinda bad
im not a big fan of the grape and kidnapping, I just hope there's a happy ending ♡
Reply
(8)
10 months ago
Rocks
F**king he**, I LOVE it. Heeseo, my son, even though you are a criminal, you are precious to me
Reply
(21)
(9)
10 months ago
Rocks
The thing is that people knew what they were getting into
And when the top suddenly acts all as.sholey people are like "HE DID NOTT!!!"
LIKE I KNOW ITS FUXKED UP BUT YOU KNEW WHAT YOU WERE GETTING INTO MARGARET
and I don't really know why you guys hate on the uke
He is one of the most precious and composed guys evaaa
I love him to bits
One more thing that pis*** me off is that people in this comment section romanticize manipulation,grape, obnoxiousess,stabbing,kidnapping,and all that fuxked up stuff
Like in another story people were rolling their eyes at stockholm syndrome
And in this story, the uke moves on temporarily and people ask him to stay loyal and love heeseo for eva and eva
I KNOW HE'S HANDSOME VERONICA AND I KNOW YOUR INTO KIDNAPPING AND SHXT BUT KEEP YOUR TEENAGE FANTASIES TO YOUR SELF
And the reason I gave it a five michellin fuxing cuxty stars Is because I like stars
And also it served it purpose
It fed me (unlike my mom)
It cures me
It skrrrt me
Fuxk me
But seriously I love this story
Everything is just so perfect for a dystopian mindset
The charactors emotions are portrayed perfectly
I've been with this story for a looooong time
When I was at my lowest it helped me get through it
I lived on just to read the new chapters
Cha Taekyung is one person I'm really grateful towards
I was one of the first readers (flex intended)
Thank you author for this masterpiece
I went through all sixty nine stages of grief (gosh darn I'm sooo proud of myself for making that joke teehee)
And you might me wondering why Im leaving such a big review
Cause I like the story and because of a petty feud with my friend (but that's for another time)
NO KAREN ITS NOT TO FILL UP THE REVIEW PAGE
BUT IT MIGHT BE
Toodles ~
And when the top suddenly acts all as.sholey people are like "HE DID NOTT!!!"
LIKE I KNOW ITS FUXKED UP BUT YOU KNEW WHAT YOU WERE GETTING INTO MARGARET
and I don't really know why you guys hate on the uke
He is one of the most precious and composed guys evaaa
I love him to bits
One more thing that pis*** me off is that people in this comment section romanticize manipulation,grape, obnoxiousess,stabbing,kidnapping,and all that fuxked up stuff
Like in another story people were rolling their eyes at stockholm syndrome
And in this story, the uke moves on temporarily and people ask him to stay loyal and love heeseo for eva and eva
I KNOW HE'S HANDSOME VERONICA AND I KNOW YOUR INTO KIDNAPPING AND SHXT BUT KEEP YOUR TEENAGE FANTASIES TO YOUR SELF
And the reason I gave it a five michellin fuxing cuxty stars Is because I like stars
And also it served it purpose
It fed me (unlike my mom)
It cures me
It skrrrt me
Fuxk me
But seriously I love this story
Everything is just so perfect for a dystopian mindset
The charactors emotions are portrayed perfectly
I've been with this story for a looooong time
When I was at my lowest it helped me get through it
I lived on just to read the new chapters
Cha Taekyung is one person I'm really grateful towards
I was one of the first readers (flex intended)
Thank you author for this masterpiece
I went through all sixty nine stages of grief (gosh darn I'm sooo proud of myself for making that joke teehee)
And you might me wondering why Im leaving such a big review
Cause I like the story and because of a petty feud with my friend (but that's for another time)
NO KAREN ITS NOT TO FILL UP THE REVIEW PAGE
BUT IT MIGHT BE
Toodles ~
Reply
(15)
(14)
10 months ago
Sucks big time
I hate this so much this has grooming the mc is still in school but hes 18 years old to make it legal while the ml 10 years older or something the mc is a disgusting rapist obsessed for no fuc**** reason everything is drawn differently than the mc and ml this story is just nad with plot holes
Reply
(19)
(3)
CHAPTERS (92)
- Chapter 88
- Chapter 87
- Chapter 86
- Chapter 85
- Chapter 84
- Chapter 83
- Chapter 82
- Chapter 81
- Chapter 80
- Chapter 79
- Chapter 78
- Chapter 77
- Chapter 76
- Chapter 75
- Chapter 74
- Chapter 73
- Chapter 72
- Chapter 71
- Chapter 70
- Chapter 69
- Chapter 68
- Chapter 67
- Chapter 66
- Chapter 65
- Chapter 64
- Chapter 63
- Chapter 62
- Chapter 61
- Chapter 60
- Chapter 59
- Chapter 58
- Chapter 57
- Chapter 56
- Chapter 55.5
- Chapter 55
- Chapter 54
- Chapter 53
- Chapter 52
- Chapter 51.5
- Chapter 50
- Chapter 51
- Chapter 49
- Chapter 48
- Chapter 47
- Chapter 46
- Chapter 45
- Chapter 44
- Chapter 43
- Chapter 42
- Chapter 41
- Chapter 40
- Hitaus. : Hiatus
- Chapter 39
- Chapter 38
- Chapter 37
- Chapter 36
- Chapter 35
- Chapter 34
- Chapter 33
- Chapter 32
- Chapter 31
- Chapter 30
- Chapter 29
- Chapter 28
- Chapter 27
- Chapter 26
- Chapter 25
- Chapter 24
- Chapter 23
- Chapter 22
- Chapter 21
- Chapter 20
- Notice. : Official Chapters
- Chapter 19
- Chapter 18
- Chapter 17
- Chapter 16
- Chapter 15
- Chapter 14
- Chapter 13
- Chapter 12
- Chapter 11
- Chapter 10
- Chapter 9
- Chapter 8
- Chapter 7
- Chapter 6
- Chapter 5
- Chapter 4
- Chapter 3
- Chapter 2
- Chapter 1
SHOW MORE
SHARE THIS MANGA
COMMENTS
Sort by :